You can buy commercial electricity directly from a retail supplier or use an energy broker to run a competitive process. The economics favor the broker approach for most accounts — not because brokers have magic pricing power, but because the competitive process itself drives better outcomes than negotiating with one supplier at a time.
Schedule a free energy consultation →
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Option A | Option B |
|---|---|---|
| Suppliers quoted | 1 (the one you called) | 30+ simultaneously |
| Competitive leverage | None | Full market competition |
| Your time required | Moderate per supplier | Low — broker handles process |
| Contract review | You do it | Broker does it |
| Market knowledge required | High | Low — broker provides context |
| Cost to you | $0 | $0 out of pocket |
| Broker fee | N/A | Paid by supplier, in every quote |
| Best for | Existing supplier you've verified | Most commercial accounts |
Why Direct Doesn't Mean Cheaper
Supplier pricing includes a broker compensation component regardless of whether you use a broker. If you go direct, the supplier keeps that margin. If you use a broker, the broker's fee comes from that same margin. Going direct doesn't save you the broker fee — it gives it to the supplier instead of a process that creates competitive pressure.
The Value of Simultaneous Competition
When you call one supplier, you get one offer. That supplier has no competitive pressure to price aggressively. When a broker submits your load profile to 30 suppliers simultaneously, they compete on the same usage basis. Market pricing means the competitive quote is almost always lower than the first offer from a single supplier.
Ready to compare commercial energy rates?
We shop 30+ suppliers at no cost to you.
What Brokers Do That You Can't Efficiently Do Alone
Run a full RFQ across all active suppliers in your market. Know which suppliers are pricing aggressively in your territory right now. Read contract fine print with experience to spot unfavorable terms. Manage the renewal calendar. Handle utility transfer paperwork. For an account renewing every 1–3 years, this process benefits from a professional running it.
When Direct Relationships Make Sense
If you have an existing supplier relationship with consistently competitive pricing, and you've verified it against market alternatives recently, maintaining that direct relationship is reasonable. But verify — many businesses assume their supplier is competitive without having run a market check in 2+ years.
The Verification Standard
The only way to know if you're getting a competitive rate — from a broker or direct — is to run a competing bid process. A broker does this by design. If you go direct, you should still get at least 3–5 competing quotes before accepting any offer. The competitive process is the tool; whether a broker runs it or you run it is secondary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does going direct to a supplier save money vs. using a broker?
No. Supplier pricing includes broker compensation regardless of whether a broker is involved. Going direct gives the supplier that margin rather than directing it to a process that creates competitive pressure.
How do brokers get paid if the customer pays nothing?
Brokers receive a per-kWh fee from the supplier you choose, built into the contract rate. This compensation structure is standard in the industry and exists in every supplier's pricing whether or not a broker is involved.
Can I verify a broker's quote against a direct price?
Yes. Call the same supplier directly and ask for a quote. You'll typically receive a higher price than what a broker quotes — because the broker creates competitive pressure that the direct call doesn't. The comparison itself demonstrates broker value.
What if I already have a good relationship with a supplier?
A good relationship with a supplier is valuable for service and contract management. But 'good relationship' shouldn't replace competitive bidding. We can include your existing supplier in a competitive process — if they remain the best option, you stay with them. If someone beats them, you have a better rate.
How long does a broker-managed quote process take?
From data authorization to competing offers: 3–5 business days. Contract execution: 1–2 days. Total from initial contact to signed contract: typically 2–3 weeks. Going direct to a single supplier is faster per-supplier but requires serial conversations rather than a simultaneous competitive process.