The decision between a 12-month and multi-year (24–36 month) commercial energy contract is fundamentally about how much budget certainty you need and how confident you are in current market pricing. Multi-year contracts reduce procurement frequency and provide extended cost visibility at the price of some market flexibility.
Schedule a free energy consultation →
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Option A | Option B |
|---|---|---|
| Budget certainty | 12 months | 24–36 months |
| Procurement events per 3 years | 3 | 1–2 |
| Market repricing opportunity | Annual | Every 2–3 years |
| ETF exposure window | 12 months max | Up to 36 months |
| Admin burden | Higher — annual renewal | Lower — less frequent |
| Price premium | None (base) | Modest (supplier risk premium) |
The Annual Contract Advantage
Annual contracts give you maximum flexibility: the ability to reprice to market every 12 months, minimal ETF exposure if your situation changes, and frequent market checks that keep your rate competitive. For accounts in volatile markets or uncertain operational situations, annual contracts are the lower-risk choice.
The Multi-Year Contract Advantage
Multi-year contracts reduce procurement overhead — instead of running a full competitive bid process every year, you run it every 2–3 years. They lock in favorable pricing for an extended period when you sign at the right market moment. They simplify budget modeling: three years of known supply costs is a real operational benefit.
Ready to compare commercial energy rates?
We shop 30+ suppliers at no cost to you.
Signing Multi-Year at the Right Moment
The key to a successful multi-year contract is signing when market conditions are favorable. In a downward price environment, signing a 3-year contract locks in elevated rates for too long. In a period when forward prices are at or below historical averages, a 3-year lock provides protection through the next up-cycle.
Multi-Site Portfolio Considerations
For multi-site accounts procuring across dozens of locations, multi-year contracts significantly reduce administrative burden. Instead of annual procurement events across every location, a 2–3 year aligned procurement covers the entire portfolio for an extended period. We design procurement calendars for multi-site clients to balance timing risk and administrative efficiency.
The Hybrid Approach
Some accounts benefit from splitting: procure half their load on a 12-month contract and half on a 24-month contract with offset expiration dates. This provides some flexibility without fully committing to annual procurement events. We model this approach for accounts where the economics support it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the typical price premium for a 36-month vs. 12-month contract?
Typically 2–6% in normal market conditions — suppliers price in the additional risk of a longer-term commitment. In specific market conditions (rising price environment), longer-term premiums may be higher; in declining markets, suppliers may price long terms more aggressively.
Can I extend a 12-month contract before it expires?
Yes — this is called 'forward pricing.' You can lock in a new contract for a future start date up to 12 months before it begins. This lets you capture favorable pricing in the forward market before your current contract expires.
Are multi-year contracts available for natural gas too?
Yes. Natural gas fixed-price contracts are available for 12–36 months in most deregulated gas markets. Multi-year gas contracts are popular for manufacturers and other gas-intensive operations seeking long-term cost certainty.
What if my business changes during a multi-year term?
ETF clauses apply to load that drops below contracted amounts (or closes). We review ETF terms before recommending any multi-year contract and advise on appropriate contracted volume relative to your expected usage range.
How does a broker handle multi-year renewals?
We set calendar reminders for 6–9 months before any contract expiration — whether 12 or 36 months. The renewal process is identical regardless of term: competitive bid, offer evaluation, execution. Longer terms just mean fewer of these events.